Daniel.

Yes, there have been a ton of computer related threads lately, but I want to make this one become more of an ongoing discussion for those of us a bit more technical than the rest.

Personally I've been debating on going custom built or prebuilt for my next rig.

I've previously custom built 2 rigs before in the Pentium4 days.
I currently use a prebuilt Hp Pavilion with a P4 3.4HT with some upgrades.

It's time for a new PC as this one is now slow as balls and is nearly 4 years old.
With the prices of prebuilt systems being so low and affordable, why should I custom build another PC?

I only use my computer for some gaming, internet and lots and lots of photo editing. I don't download music or movies and I probably wouldn't use it as a HTPC.

So I basically have two questions, should I go prebuilt or custom and should I get an i7 or a Core2 Quad?


I'm really on the fence on whether or not I need/want a Core i7 system.
Pros
-Faster
-Better for gaming with multiple GPU's
-won't be phased out for a long time

Cons
-cost prohibitive

Would I even be able to take advantage of the speed in an i7 rig with Photoshop? Is it worth the extra 300-400 bucks?

Should I just get a bare bones i7 system now, and save my money till the cost of DDR3 goes down?

One major thing about the prebuilt systems is that they come with W7 installed. I'd have to front the cost of the OS separately if I went custom again.

Sorry, If my post was all over the place. I'm really scatter brained this morning and haven't had my coffee yet.

__________________

Soooshi

Sadly, the price of prebuild machines are a lot better on the wallet than DIY setups.

Premade, upgrade.

__________________
<imgsrc="http://img134.imageshack.us/img134/6123/siggyx.png">

Mangudai

Its really a decision that you'll have to make on your own. Analyze the price/performance ratio between the two and decide. Besides that, you can build a computer cheaper than a prebuilt if you catch deals and buy used. Just take your time and decide, also how long do you need it to last you? How many games do you play, what games coming out do you plan to play? What resolution? These are questions you gotta ask yourself.


Curious, what price point are you looking at?

There are many sites that have direct comparisons to show performance difference, here's one


http://www.tomshardware.com/charts/2...hmarks,60.html



Also, have you considered i5?

__________________
Almost there.

Daniel.

This is kinda broad, but I'm looking to spend between 500 and 1k.

To be honest, I could wait and hunt for the best deals, but I don't think I have the patience for it haha.

My current system has lasted me about 4 years so I'd say this new one would probably have to last me AT LEAST 2-3 years.

I don't really play computer games that often anymore. I used to play WoW a bunch and the only games I see myself playing in the future would be Diablo 3 and Starcraft 2. They don't seem to be too graphics intensive compared to COD4, Far Cry or Crysis.

I'd most likely be playing at 1920x1200.

My personal situation aside, what's everyone's thoughts on the Core i7/i5 line of chips?

Isn't Intel also working to integrate a GPU controller into their new 35nm chips?

__________________

evmal613

Prebuilt systems are easier on the wallet for sure, and easier maintainence. I currently have a hp prebuilt with a phenom x4, and barely costs me anything. I work as a pc technician, and honestly I get more headaches from custom builts than anything else. You never know how custom builts were put together and in the end seems to cause more problems. Like what people have been saying, prebuilt is alot more cost effective, especially since gaming is occasional. Upgrade prebuilt, ram, cpu, gpu, hd, etc. Its just as easy. One thing I dont like is that the memory is one of the lowest fsb ratings. For instance when pc2-8400 is out, i get the pc2-6400. Its cheaper to SAY there is 8 gb's then 8 gb's of 1066 memory. haha. overall though, prebuilt is recommended for the price and performance you want. 500-1k is great for a prebuilt unit, HP is selling one wit the i7 for 999.99 on their website, check it out

SimpleS14

Go with a pre-built that is upgradable.

I can't speak for the i5/i7 because my current PC is a custom built unit with a Core 2 Quad, and its more than enough for me. I don't play games, but I do use Photoshop.

__________________
Goals are dreams with a deadline.
MA240SX
L.H.O.O.Q.

Daniel.

So this is what I've built at Hp for $932

On a setup like this, how easy would it be to replace the mobo at a later date?

Could I just get a new one, swap over everything and be good to go?

What about potential bloatware on the OS from HP? Can I get rid of that somehow?

I'm reading that on a Core i7 rig, 1333mhz mem is definitely a plus over 1066. I wish DDR3 was cheaper right now...

__________________

aznpoopy

custom.

fuck prebuilts and their shitty components and their shitty layouts. the only good prebuilt i ever had was a 400mhz p2 dell from like 1998. everything on that computer still works today. on every other prebuilt i ever got, retarded shit fails left and right. reader on optical drive got stuck. video card fan spun itself out of the fan casing. hard drive bearing went bad. etc. etc. etc.

just because a prebuilt and custom have matching specs doesn't mean they are equal. quality of the actual components (see above) and layout of the build (inclusion of case fans, size of cpu fan, thinking about airflow) is all stuff that doesn't get advertised. so it usually sucks. i had one prebuilt that arrived with the cpu fan doubling as the case fan. hilarious.

Daniel.

Could I remove everything from a prebuilt case and just install all of it in my own case and add fans?

__________________

aznpoopy

i don't see why not.

things may not fit, line up with holes, plug connectors to the case might be different etc. but that's simple problem solving... drilling, wiring, etc.

well, that's assuming the motherboard will support the extra fans you plan to use.

Vision Garage

Why would do take everything from a prebuilt only to replace it again? its like a car. Better to do it right the first time. I myself would rather custom a computer over prebuilt any day. If you know your shit, you can get your custom for cheaper and with better quality parts for sure.

heres a custom from tigerdirect which will kill the HP one your customized. Cost a bit more but the parts are worth it.

ASUS P6T Intel X58 Barebone Kit - Socket LGA1366, Intel Core i7 920, 12GB Corsair DDR3-1600, 1.5TB SATA2, Clear Side ATX Mid-Tower, 750W at TigerDirect.com

__________________

Vision Garage

and one in your price range.

XFX X58i Core i7 LGA1366 Barebone Kit - Intel Core i7 920 CPU 2.66GHz, 12GB DDR3, 1TB HDD, Full-Tower Case, 750 Watt PSU at TigerDirect.com

__________________

aznpoopy

^werd^

just saw these q's

it depends. dell and hp, etc. dell/hp/etc. often go with proprietary plugs, fitment, etc. instead of industry standard. so new motherboard in a hp/dell case? dell - no. hp - maybe. i would guess probably not. 1) it probably wont fit in the case and 2) you probably wont be able to plug it in (power supply being a big one - they sell dell to atx power supply adapters).

read this:
InformIT: Dell proprietary (non-standard) ATX design > Dell proprietary (non-standard) ATX design

bloatware? uninstall it. all of it. or just do a fresh install of the OS right from the start. if you didn't receive a copy of it from dell/hp/etc with the computer, you should be able to request one, often for free or a nominal fee.

Daniel.

Cool, thanks. That's really helpful.

Thanks, I totally forgot about Tiger Direct. I've been shopping on Newegg for the past couple of weeks.

That's a great price for the rig. Only thing is, I'd still be responsible for a video card and the OS. That's about another $120 for W7 Home Premium, and probably around $100 for an entry level graphics card...

I also need a Compact Flash internal card reader to dump my photos onto. Maybe tack on another $20?

It'd be manageable for my budget, but the less I spend, the better.

__________________

Om1kron

FOR FUCKING REAL

I was just telling my roommate staples has a dell desktop with an amd athlon x2 3.6ghz 4gig ram raedon 3200 integrated graphics and 360gig hd with a 21 inch widescreen monitor all in one box for 600 bucks.

with windows 7 home edition

fuck me.

I would literally just have to put my graphics card in that box and I'm reads to go.

I'm also looking at upgrading and it's not looking cheap. I want at least 8 gigs of ram if not 16. (i do a lot of photoshop work.)

__________________
Wayne T. Edwards
Violent Running Tribe News Blog <---Peep This

Om1kron

also imo windows 7 professional edition is all anyone should need. the ultimate edition just has security options that seriously are not even necessary for a home machine.

__________________
Wayne T. Edwards
Violent Running Tribe News Blog <---Peep This

Vision Garage

daniel, if you are looking for something that will do the job but wont break your bank, I would rather you get an AMD processor. Yes they are not up to par with intel but AMD is more geared the budget minded. You wouldnt really be able to tell teh difference unless you are a real hardcore gamer.

On that note...

Asus M4A785-M Phenom X4 9750 Barebone Kit - AMD Phenom X4 9750 2.4GHz, 4GB DDR2, 750GB HDD, XFX Radeon HD 4350, DVDRW, ATX Case, 650 Watt PSU, Windows 7 Home Premium OEM at TigerDirect.com

__________________

future240

I agree whole heartedly with this. A good MB(Asrock works great for me) with a Phenom II 940/955/965 processor, 4GBS of 1066 ram(Gskill) and a Radeon( I prefer HIS) 5870 will do you real good.

__________________
ZOMG A NEW FORUM BY THE CREATORS OF ZIVLIA?!!!

Join us at http://boostaholic.org/


Become my pupil
Future240 My Brute
Become part of the Zilvia Clan

http://mybrute.com/team/8715

Bobadrift

I'm currently in the middle of building a new PC and I decided to use the Shuttle SX58-H7. I'm not a hardcore gamer so a cube PC works for me.
For parts I would look at Ewiz (Superbiiz), Newegg, Tigerdirect, and Amazon. So far the cheapest I've seen is Ewiz for parts.
I'm not building an ultimate gaming machine, but rather one I can use for multiple functions including Blu-Ray playback for my LCD TV.

bardabe

Windows 7 Ultimate, get it you will love it, I love it. Ive only been running it for about 3 days but it fuckin rules.

__________________
BARDABE PERFORMANCE DEVELOPMENT
Custom Fabrication, Wiring Services, and Parts Development
Welded Diferentials, Lifetime Warranty
no questions asked
Review Thread

future240

I agree with this, I have been running it since October 27th and this shit is great.

__________________
ZOMG A NEW FORUM BY THE CREATORS OF ZIVLIA?!!!

Join us at http://boostaholic.org/


Become my pupil
Future240 My Brute
Become part of the Zilvia Clan

http://mybrute.com/team/8715

Daniel.

Thanks for the links fellas.

The more I think about it, the more I'm sure that a prebuilt with room to upgrade is the right choice for my budget.

Oh and, bardabe and future, I'm not sure if you guys are trying to close me on W7 or W7 Ultimate specifically, but I've already decided on W7 Home.

I don't need any of the additional features on Ult. Bitlocker encryption? No thanks.

__________________

Gnnr

This is true. The reason that prebuilt systems are so cheap is because they have contracts with manufactures to mass produce specific components for them. But they are usually cheap in quality.

Read this if you're going custom

Ars System Guide: October 2009 Edition - Ars Technica

__________________

SimpleS14

It's good that you've made up your mind.

Windows 7 Home Premium is good enough for you.

__________________
Goals are dreams with a deadline.
MA240SX
L.H.O.O.Q.

future240

Agreed,

just make sure you get the 64 bit version.

__________________
ZOMG A NEW FORUM BY THE CREATORS OF ZIVLIA?!!!

Join us at http://boostaholic.org/


Become my pupil
Future240 My Brute
Become part of the Zilvia Clan

http://mybrute.com/team/8715

Daniel.

Of course! I wouldn't purposely handicap myself at a 4gb ram limit with the 32bit.

__________________

unlegendary

if u want a custom build, get all your hardware parts NON integrated because anything integrated is not efficient and more $$ from your wallet to upgrade. if you're gonna run vista or windows 7 premium while being a gaming nerd, then you're gonna have run minimum 3 gigs of memory.

__________________
Full Time Student until 2011 = sad

BOROSUN

no point getting 5800 yet. i went with 4870 until dx11 starts heating up and 5800 price lowers.

I would get the 5700 runs the same spec as 4800's and a cheap dx11 card.

also the 956 price just got lower. ddr3 all the way

__________________
Vaseline wins fights!!! .

Mangudai

For $1000 and your needs I say definitely build an AMD rig, actually I could probably pull if an i7 if you price it right. An i7 920 and a 4670 together don't make any sense though. Whether or not going 5800 is really up to the person. There are many different variables.

__________________
Almost there.

Daniel.

Everyone keeps forgetting that if I go custom, I have to purchase the OS too...

__________________